Taeeun Yoo makes a big splash into the fishbowl that is children's writing.
THREE PROS
*My son has about 15 new books to choose from this week, but this is the only one he wants us to read
*Other authors would be happy to create something half as imaginative
*Whale shadow...'nuff said
*Whale shadow...'nuff said
THREE CONS
*The story itself doesn't speak to me in quite the same way as it does to my boy
*There's no doubting the magical qualities of the book, but I have to admit I don't quite get if there is a point to the whole thing
*There are a few pages without words, which is fine in and of itself, but they still force you to guess at the logic behind them
ONE DAD'S OPINION
Where do I start with this review? At first blush, I didn't really like the book all that much and figured I was going to give it a Donate when I eventually sat down to review it. But within minutes I saw just how drawn my kid was to this little red fish, and started to reconsider. With each passing reading, I focused more and more on the positive qualities it has, most of which revolve around the mysticism that teems out of the second half of the book. If I was a little less straitlaced, I might have thrown a Buy at it, but by now you know I'm a fairly red-blooded American male, so it gets a Borrow. [I know the font is messed up again, but it's getting more screwy when I try to fix it, so I'm just leaving it.]
Buy / BORROW / Donate / Destroy
ONE DAD'S OPINION
Where do I start with this review? At first blush, I didn't really like the book all that much and figured I was going to give it a Donate when I eventually sat down to review it. But within minutes I saw just how drawn my kid was to this little red fish, and started to reconsider. With each passing reading, I focused more and more on the positive qualities it has, most of which revolve around the mysticism that teems out of the second half of the book. If I was a little less straitlaced, I might have thrown a Buy at it, but by now you know I'm a fairly red-blooded American male, so it gets a Borrow. [I know the font is messed up again, but it's getting more screwy when I try to fix it, so I'm just leaving it.]
Buy / BORROW / Donate / Destroy
1 comment:
Boring book, I don't know why it remids me another boring book: Chica chica Boom Boom
Post a Comment