THREE PROS
*Luke Flowers is a miracle worker of sorts -- in that he creates illustrations that take your breath away
*While I wish Flowers and author Brian J. Hunt would have dedicated at least one page to a representation of the results of the cannon shot process (as in how Miles' job affected people in real time), the overall idea was very creative
*Absolutely loved how Hunt pegged the ideal temperature for glow at normal human body temperature without coming out and making the connection
THREE CONS
*I still don't get why the factory wasn't destroyed after the first sabotage attempt (if Jack only rescued people) and I really don't get why Corbin thinks the exact same plan will accomplish it
*Most of the miracles cited were weak or involved tinges of hometown favoritism
*There are a couple of places where things aren't depicted as they were earlier described: namely the lack of a division scar on page 23 and a factory that is actually not taller than the eye can see on page 26
ONE DAD'S OPINION
I've literally sat and prayed for divine guidance on how I should rate this book. [Okay, so it was mainly because I wanted to write the previous sentence, but, still, it's true :)] Marvelously, it worked!! After going back and forth a few times, I had a revelation and decided that Miracle Miles is a definite Borrow. In reality, the rating was never in question, given the polarizing pros and cons listed above. In short, there's a lot to love about the story but you'll be left with a lingering sensation that you want something more.
1 comment:
I'm guessing you screen your blog posts first, so I'm not writing to the planet. And if I am, that works too.
I'm representing a team of Deaf and hearing writers, artists and illustrators who are creating amazing books with DVDs (they ARE amazing really) that let all kids experience magical ASL storytelling.
Kids and parents can have fun just being exposed to real ASL, or they can actually build a foundation in ASL grammar and structure, and in Deaf Culture.
We have 2 new books, a few still relatively unfound ones, and one more on the way.
Send to where? Email info@asltales.net.
Many thanks,
Laurie
ASL Tales Team member
www.ASLTales.net
Post a Comment